about summary refs log tree commit diff
diff options
context:
space:
mode:
authorpjotrp <pjotr.public01@thebird.nl>2026-10-18 14:29:57 +0200
committerpjotrp <pjotr.public01@thebird.nl>2026-10-18 14:29:57 +0200
commitb8ac1241e48d8cb71dd16322a3f1c9879a63beaa (patch)
treeee7bab3ac35dbd727ec15fe53595ee8c79826223
parent397732300606ad7b7b14139d364f2c17466a0603 (diff)
downloadguix-bioinformatics-julia-bump.tar.gz
Add info on julia binary inclusion julia-bump
-rw-r--r--gn/packages/julia-bin.scm38
1 files changed, 31 insertions, 7 deletions
diff --git a/gn/packages/julia-bin.scm b/gn/packages/julia-bin.scm
index 0f3f1fd..58e7b65 100644
--- a/gn/packages/julia-bin.scm
+++ b/gn/packages/julia-bin.scm
@@ -9,14 +9,38 @@
 ;;;
 ;;; The tarball is built for a generic glibc system and expects an FHS
 ;;; /lib64 loader; we patchelf every ELF file to the store's glibc and add
-;;; the gcc runtime libraries to the run path.
+;;; the gcc runtime libraries to the run path.  It also bundles its own
+;;; libcurl, so Julia's Downloads does not hit the Julia 1.8 +
+;;; system-libcurl crash ("curlmultiassign") that the Guix source build
+;;; suffers from.
 ;;;
-;;; Status (julia-bump branch): this packages and runs Julia 1.10.9.  The
-;;; existing notebook stack (Pluto 0.19.9 and friends) does NOT yet load on
-;;; it -- the first failures are MLStyle ("type DataType has no field
-;;; size"), then Expronicon, Configurations and Pluto.  Bumping those (and
-;;; whatever they pull in) to versions that support Julia 1.10 is the
-;;; remaining work; see julia-pluto et al. in gn/packages/julia.scm.
+;;; Status (julia-bump branch): this packages and runs Julia 1.10.9, and
+;;; the modern notebook stack (Pluto 1.0, PlutoSliderServer 1.9) runs on
+;;; it -- see pluto-notebook in gn/packages/julia.scm.
+;;;
+;;; A from-source Julia 1.10 was also attempted, as `julia-1.10` in
+;;; gn/packages/julia-source.scm (which inherits the 1.8.5 recipe from
+;;; (gnu packages julia)).  It does not yet build.  It gets through LLVM
+;;; 15 (built from source), the three deps that 1.8 did not have (the
+;;; Julia LLVM fork, JuliaSyntax and ittapi -- seeded into deps/srccache
+;;; from origins), and most of julia-base; it then fails compiling Julia's
+;;; own src/pipeline.cpp:
+;;;
+;;;   error: use of deleted function
+;;;   'llvm::PassManager<...>::PassManager(const llvm::PassManager<...>&)'
+;;;
+;;; Julia 1.10 copies PassManager, which only works with Julia's patched
+;;; LLVM fork, whereas the Guix recipe links Julia against *system* LLVM
+;;; (USE_SYSTEM_LLVM, and libLLVM_jll symlinked to the system library).
+;;; Finishing the source build therefore needs the recipe reworked to
+;;; build and use the fork's LLVM (drop USE_SYSTEM_LLVM and the llvm
+;;; input, and rework the shared-objects-paths phase), plus likely more
+;;; (e.g. SuiteSparse 7 library names).  Upstream Guix is still on Julia
+;;; 1.8.5 for the same reason, so there is no newer recipe to borrow.
+;;;
+;;; julia-bin is the supported way to get Julia 1.10 here; `julia-1.10`
+;;; (julia-source.scm) is kept as work-in-progress documentation of how
+;;; far a from-source build gets and where it is blocked.
 
 (define-module (gn packages julia-bin)
   #:use-module (gnu packages)