| Age | Commit message (Collapse) | Author |
|
44 of this deployment's `.geno` files carry `cM` and no `Mb` column, and
none of them could be scanned. GeneNetwork3's wrapper (copied verbatim
here) assumes the position columns are `Chr, Locus, cM, Mb` and then starts
the samples at a hardcoded column 5. On a cM-only file that is one column
too far, so the genotype block loses its first individual and the whole scan
dies in `do.call(rbind, ...)` with "number of columns of result is not a
multiple of vector length" -- a message that says nothing about the cause.
The wrapper now picks the map column from whichever of the requested scale
and the file's own columns exists (falling back, and saying so), and starts
the samples right after the position columns; the sex default and the
sample-count guard use the same count. `scripts/qtl_fitqtl.R` had the same
assumption and got the same fix.
This is the second deliberate deviation from GeneNetwork3's script, after
the sample-count guard, and both are commented as such at the code.
* scripts/rqtl_wrapper.R, scripts/qtl_fitqtl.R: the position column and the
first sample column are computed, not assumed.
* tests/test_data/rqtl_sample1_cm.geno: the existing fixture with `Mb`
dropped -- same panel, cM only.
* tests/rqtl.rs: `a_cm_only_genotype_file_maps` scans it and asserts all six
markers come back (the failure mode was five-vs-six columns, not an
error message that pointed at the genotype file).
* src/rqtl.rs, src/routes/rqtl.rs: the docs said the script never forwards
`--scale`; it does, and now falls back, so the request field says what
`pos` is in.
Verified through the API: DGRP (cM-only) now maps (3 markers), and AXB (499
markers) and BXD.4 (3 811) are unchanged.
307 tests pass; the same four as before do not.
|
|
Same request/response shape as /compute/gemma: synchronous (no job
queue), ?id= + GET /compute/rqtl/status/{run_id} progress-streaming.
Extracted that streaming infrastructure (run_streaming, create_run_log/
RunLogError, status/StatusError, RunStatus/RunStatusParams,
is_valid_run_id, COMPLETION_MARKER) out of src/gemma.rs into a new
src/streaming.rs so both compute endpoints share it instead of
duplicating it; src/routes/gemma.rs updated to the shared names,
confirmed its own 8 tests still pass unchanged.
scripts/rqtl_wrapper.R is GeneNetwork3's script, copied here verbatim
and run via Rscript -- same reasoning as reusing gemma-wrapper rather
than reimplementing GEMMA. Scope: a single scan (scanone) plus, if
nperm > 0, its permutation thresholds (67th/95th percentile, via a
Rust port of numpy.percentile's default linear interpolation) -- the
common case. Not implemented: covariates, interval mapping,
permutation strata, pair-scan (scantwo) -- scantwo in particular needs
cross-referencing the genotype file for nearest-marker lookups and a
second (MAP_) output file, a materially bigger port than this covers.
One fix relative to GeneNetwork3, found by reading the code (no test
covers the real caller's keys): generate_rqtl_cmd's content hash only
ever looks at kwargs keyed "g"/"p", but gn3/api/rqtl.py's real caller
uses keys "geno"/"pheno" -- they never match, so the genotype/
phenotype file contents never actually enter the cache-key hash in
production, only the other options. Two different phenotypes mapped
with the same other options would get the same cached output filename
and silently reuse each other's result. Fixed here: both files'
contents are always hashed (std DefaultHasher -- a cache key, not a
security boundary, so no need for GeneNetwork3's md5).
guix.scm: r, r-qtl, r-optparse, r-stringi and r-stringr added as
propagated-inputs (same category as gemma-wrapper, and same reasoning:
invoked as a subprocess, not linked). All stock Guix -- confirmed the
existing -L (needed only for gemma-wrapper, from guix-bioinformatics)
is not needed for these; the dev shell has Rscript/R-qtl on PATH from
guix.scm's own propagated-inputs alone.
Test fixture: a small, hand-written, valid BXD riset genotype/
phenotype pair (tests/test_data/rqtl_sample1.*), not GeneNetwork3's
own tests/unit/db/.../genotype_sample1.geno -- that fixture has a
genotype code outside its own header's declared set and duplicate
marker names across chromosomes, harmless for the unrelated parsing
unit it's written for there, but both would break a real R/qtl run.
Verified end to end, not just unit tested: tests/rqtl.rs runs the real
Rscript/R-qtl against that fixture (a real scanone scan, real
permutation thresholds with suggestive <= significant, the run-id-
collision 409 pre-seeded with no Rscript needed, and the completion
marker landing in a real log after the run finishes). cargo test
passes in full.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
|
Maps a QTL from a genotype file, a SNP annotation file and trait
values, by running gemma-wrapper's K-matrix step then its LMM
association step, both synchronously (axum/tokio awaits the subprocess
directly, no job queue needed) and returning the parsed .assoc.txt
rows in the standard envelope.
Both steps use a bare --loco (gemma-wrapper derives the chromosome
list from the SNP annotation file). This was arrived at empirically,
not from GeneNetwork3's or GeneNetwork2's own gemma code: run for real
against the BXD fixtures,
- GeneNetwork3's gn3/computations/gemma.py composes a GWA command that
always keeps "-gk" alongside "-lmm"; real GEMMA rejects that
combination outright ("only one of -gk ... -lmm ... options is
allowed"), so none of its gwa-compute/k-gwa-compute endpoints can
produce output. Unsurprising: tests/integration/test_gemma.py is
entirely @unittest.skip, so this was never exercised.
- GeneNetwork2's wqflask/marker_regression/gemma_mapping.py correctly
omits "-gk" from the GWA step, but its non-LOCO branch fails too,
the same way my own first (non-LOCO) attempt did: gemma-wrapper only
ever archives a non-LOCO kinship matrix into a .tar.xz, with no
loose file at the path its own non-LOCO GWA code assumes
("Enforce failed for file_kin ... open file"). Only --loco, which
gemma-wrapper's own USAGE banner documents and which does unpack
that archive, actually works.
A --loco run's .assoc.txt files (one per chromosome) are themselves
only ever inside gemma-wrapper's own output archive, never loose, so
gemma.rs shells out to `tar` (one of gemma-wrapper's own propagated
dependencies) to extract them before concatenating all chromosomes'
rows into the response.
guix.scm now depends on (gn packages gemma) from guix-bioinformatics
for gemma-wrapper (propagated-input: it's invoked as a subprocess, not
linked, and this makes it land in a consuming profile too, same as
GeneNetwork3's and GeneNetwork2's own packages do it). That dependency
needed guix-bioinformatics' own gn/packages/gemma.scm fixed first (see
that repo's fix/gemma-which-shadowing branch) -- gemma-gn2 would not
build at all before that fix.
Verified end to end: `cargo test` passes in full, including a real
(non-mocked, non-skipped) run of gemma-wrapper/GEMMA against the BXD
fixtures copied from genenetwork3/tests/test_data, producing exactly
7320 association rows (one per marker in BXD_snps.txt) in ~19s.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|