about summary refs log tree commit diff
path: root/test/python/test_groups.py
diff options
context:
space:
mode:
authorPjotr <wrk@bosa.lan>2026-11-16 00:30:52 +0000
committerPjotr <wrk@bosa.lan>2026-11-16 00:30:52 +0000
commit278855bd0014094a9d3fcf81ef387e1aa7a89068 (patch)
treed2c12bb182ab6f663355bb5dc6259eed939b675e /test/python/test_groups.py
parent1ae2f5d712e18c016fdb7bd04da99eab4da6915b (diff)
downloadgenenetwork4-278855bd0014094a9d3fcf81ef387e1aa7a89068.tar.gz
gemma: suggest BulkLMM rotations for a threshold, with the numbers
GEMMA's reply offered R/qtl as the way to get significance thresholds,
which is the wrong advice for a relatedness-structured panel: haley-knott's
permutation shuffles phenotypes without regard to the kinship, so its null
is anti-conservative exactly where an LMM was chosen in the first place.
BulkLMM is the same model family as this scan and permutes by rotating the
data through the kinship decomposition, so its thresholds do respect
relatedness -- and it is fast.

The 200 reply now carries three actions in order: draw it (/plot/gemma),
POST /compute/bulklmm with a ready-to-post body (group, trait_name,
samples, nperm 500, seed 1), then POST /compute/rqtl relabelled as a
non-LMM cross-check with a warning that its threshold is anti-conservative
here.

Measured on BXD trait 10001, so the text asserts nothing it has not seen:
GEMMA's best marker is rsm10000005700 on chr8 (p_lrt 5.9e-07, -log10 p
6.23) and BulkLMM's best is the same marker (LOD 3.866, beta -0.0615) --
at the peak the two LMM families agree on the locus. Their thresholds are
not interchangeable: with 500 rotations BulkLMM's 0.05 threshold is LOD
3.78 (the peak clears it, and a second seed gave 3.62), while R/qtl2's
LOCO scan1perm on the same trait and permutation count gives 2.62, so a
global kinship is the stricter null; and LOD 3.87 and -log10 p 6.23 are
different scales for one marker, so a BulkLMM threshold must never be
compared with a GEMMA p-value directly.

The 422 permutations_not_supported text quotes the same measurements
instead of prose, and the suggested body was run verbatim to check it:
POST /compute/bulklmm with it returns 200, 21056 rows, and the threshold
note "500 rotations (seed 1): alpha 0.01 LOD 4.10, alpha 0.05 LOD 3.62".
Diffstat (limited to 'test/python/test_groups.py')
0 files changed, 0 insertions, 0 deletions